Published on Thursday, October 11th, 2007 at 12:51 am

bob dylan smoking

Last week the Bob Dylan canon saw yet another re-packing; this time in the form of DYLAN, a career-spanning three disc retrospective chronicling the artist’s four decades of studio recordings. While Dylan purists and pundits will undoubtedly own the majority of the albums these tracks are pulled from, the set does lay out (over the course of its three discs) a fairly judicious overview of the artists career.

We have one box set to give away to an A.D. reader. To get it, leave a comment below with your favorite Dylan outtake (can be released or unreleased), your name, and a valid email address. Winner will be contacted via email by Sunday night.

Download:
MP3:
Bob Dylan :: Simple Twist of Fate
———-
Amazon: Bob Dylan - Dylan (Box)

www.bobdylan.com ++ www.expectingrain.com ++ more dylan mp3s

+ Check eMusic’s 25 free MP3 no risk trial offer
—————————————————————————————————————
+ Visit The Hype Machine for additional Bob Dylan MP3s

Related Posts

115 Responses to “Dylan :: Retrospective Box Giveaway”

  1. The tracklist says it all. This is the ultimate Dylan collection. However, I suggest everyone to buy individual albums. They’re cheap! And that way you get the whole picture…

    My favourite Dylan outtake at the moment is “Forever Young”, the Last Waltz version.

  2. Yo..
    I have enjoyed discovering new music, and appreciating old favs once again through yer site.The dylan track i believe needs more love is I’ll keep it with Mine, just better than syphillis.

  3. My favorite Dylan outtake would have to be “This Land Is Your Land (Live Version)”, track 3 of Disc 1 of The Bootleg Series, Vol. 7: No Direction Home: The Soundtrack. Maybe a bit academic, but this version adds a bone-weary desolation that perfectly fits the classic tune. It gives you a glimpse of what turned Dylan from another young folkie into who he became; getting deeply into these Guthrie tunes was his crossroad.

  4. It took me a while to begin to narrow down the list of great Dylan bootlegs. I think Farewell Angelina is a fantastic song. For some reason the line “shooting tin cans with a sawed-off shotgun” has always stuck out to me.

  5. Yo - so, I’m completely into the idea of this give away, don’t know if i’m all too late, but I have two favorites… one of which is the BLUES version of “leopard skin pillbox hat” which is on a bootleg series tape… and no direction home… It’s just so good - and Mike Bloomfield’s guitar work is brilliant, even though it’s a bob song w/ so many lyrics, it still shines.

    But the other is a real fucking good one to listen to, and one of the main pieces of evidence to prove that marijuana (and possibly other drugs) are AMAZING…

    It’s from the basement tapes with the hawks / the band… “see you later alligator, see you later alligator - see you later crocodile, see you later crocagator… See you later alligator - see you later alan ginsberg…” it’s the giggliest jamb that is just so much fun, and it’s just - it’s what me and the boys do when we sit around and write stupid songs…

  6. the live Hurricane from Bootlegs vol. 6 is pretty badass

  7. My favourite Dylan outtake? Oh, that’s easy: “Desolation Row” from “No Direction Home: The Soundtrack”.

  8. My favourite is “Tears of Rage” from The Basement Tapes, recorded with The Band. I’ve been playing it on the guitar a lot recently, and it makes me feel so emotional when I do, that I almost want to weep. It’s just beautiful.

  9. One of my favorite songs is the version of Tangled Up in Blue he played live with the Grateful Dead in July 1987.
    Its an almost joyful rendition of the song as Dylan and the Dead try to outdo each other, Dylan with his increasingly varying vocals and the Dead with their backup instrumentals and jam sessions during the breaks. As the song progresses, Dylan really begins belting out his words, and sometimes even Jerry helps him emphasize the last lines of a lyric.
    In short, the song is a function of the added energy of each part which contribute to the new overpoweringly optimistic feeling of this version of the timeless song.

  10. Easy. “Catfish” from Bootleg Series Vol. 1-3 (61-91). Worth it for the harmonica sound alone. Not only is it a “Desire” outtake (my favorite Dylan album), but it’s a tribute to a man who pitched a perfect game, won a Cy Young, won 5 world series, and had an INSANE mustache, to boot. His credentials are impeccable and I challenge you to come up with a better nickname than “Catfish”.

  11. It might be an obvious one, by I love “Leopard Skin Pill Box Hat” from the Live at the Royal Albert Hall 1966 album… just send brilliant shivers down my spine and whilst my feet won’t stop tapping away. Genius.

  12. Note to the

  13. Note to the new compilation: “DYLAN”

    “Someone showed me a picture and I just laughed
    Dignity never been photographed
    I went into the red, went into the black
    Into the valley of dry bone dreams” from: DIGNITY

    Favourite outtake: “Moonlight”, Live in Frankfurt, Germany, 2003

  14. I still can’t believe that the Oh Mercy outtake of Born In Time remains unreleased. It’s one of Dylan’s most affecting vocal performances: as Clinton Heylin said, “Just when I knew who to thank, you went blank” may look terrible on the page, but Dylan makes it work a treat.

  15. This box is pretty pointless, considering that there are so many excellent Dylan compilations on the market already, and most fans will already have the albums featuring their favourites (I have ‘em all). At least Sony resisted the temptation to include the usual handful of unreleased tracks to sucker us into buying the same stuff we already own yet again.

    Favourite outtake: “She’s Your Lover Now” - such a brilliant complex song; other artists would have built a whole career on it, and Dylan tosses it away casually without even bothering to complete it.

  16. I suppose I’ll pick Girl of the North Country with Johnny Cash. Maybe it’s just personal nostalgia talking, but that’s the first one I thought of :)

  17. fave track… hmmm…. hurricane… subterranean homesick blues… highlands… maggie’s farm… ? at the end of the day, the most oft-played, the most enjoyment comes from… highlands! 16 minutes of bliss.

  18. Someone said it before but “she’s your lover now” will have to be it for me as well.

    I saw Dylan live a few years ago, it was kind of good to see such a big rack of guitars behind the man.

  19. So many to choose from that it depends on your mood, actually. But the manic live version of “Isis” from the Biograph Box Set would be a great bet any day.

  20. The best Dylan outtake would have to be “Oh, Sister” from Live 1975 The Bootleg Series.

  21. A masterpiece: Blind Willie McTell. Should have been put on Infidels which would have benefited from it’s inclusion. I refer to the Studio version since the handful of live versions I have heard do not have the impact that the studio version does.

  22. My favorite outtake is the version of “I’ll Keep It With Mine” that appears on The Bootleg Series 1-3, recorded 1/27/66, with Al Kooper, Robbie Robertson, and Rick Danko. There’s this brief passage , lasting only the final 30 seconds of the song, where the band really takes off; Dylan’s going nuts on the piano, and Robertson’s playing these wonderful licks. It’s a very subtle, brief moment, but one that makes you sit up and take notice every time.

  23. Either Blind Willie Mctell, or the live version of Hurricaine from the Rolling Thunder volume of the Bootleg series.

  24. How ’bout that great self-parody he did with the Replacements - “Like a Rolling Pin?” Man, who knew he would wander into the recording studio that day. A great day in music. Two of Minnesota’s finest?

    What’s that?

    Not him? Whatever.

    Okay, uh, “Going to Acapulco” off The Basement Tapes has been in my head a lot in the last few months. I’ll go with that.

  25. “Baby Please Don’t Go” off the Freewheelin’ Sessions Outtakes is my personal fave

  26. I’m gonna say Blind Willie McTell - heard it on a promo disc for the Bootleg Volumes 1-3, and I think it’s THE track that started me on the way to being a Dylanhead. With Series of Dreams, off the same set, a close second

  27. Favorite outtake - High Away (also known as “Ah Ah Ah”) from the Shot of Love sessions. I put that on repeat for about a month straight after finding it.

  28. Up To Me

  29. “I’m Not There (1956),” which is finally getting an official release on the soundtrack of the (almost) same name.

  30. Favorite outtake original version of It’s All Over Now, Baby Blue.
    It’s always fresh no mather how much i listen to it.

  31. Isis from 1975 Rolling Thunder Revue

  32. wow that’s a tough one, but right now I’d say “I’ll Keep It With Mine” on Biograph and also a slightly different version (still just bob-and-piano) off of this Blonde on Blonde studio-outtake bootleg (the opening banter is almost as good as the song, too).

  33. I’ll have to go with the entire bootleg box “Genuine Live 1966″, portions of which have since been officially released, but most of which is still underground. Hearing how Dylan and the Hawks tore their way across England and Australia, in front of frequently hostile audiences, you have to think that, to this day, it’s still the greatest rock tour of all time.

  34. Odds and Ends from the Band’s great box set A Musical History. Dylan with the Band. Great track!

  35. My favourite has to be ‘Mama you’ve been on my mind’ from Bootleg Series 1-3, Cant believe he never released it an absolute heartbreaker of a song. Jeff Buckley does a stunning version of it too.

  36. I love the intensity of ‘Isis’ performed with the The Rolling Thunder Revue on the 1975 bootleg. Here is a link to a video of them performing part of it in 1975 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lZWz-9×68uM. A fine example of how great concerts used to be. Also if you haven’t read ‘On the Road With Bob Dylan’ by Larry Sloman you should pick it up. A great look into this Dylan tour.

  37. dylan box eh?

    hard to argue with Isis from the rolling thunder revue 75 boot…but the guy right above me just said that!!! and about 10 people above him.

    how about IT AIN’T ME BABE from “BEFORE THE FLOOD” with the Band? about as energetic as you’ll ever find bob, and the Band is the perfect sound (despite the overuse of synths all over that album)

  38. There are so many amazing outtakes that I’d like to mention, but I guess my sentimental favorite is “Abandoned Love” — a song I first heard on a George Harrison bootleg and came to love before I ever heard the wonderful Dylan recording.

  39. Being from Nashville, I am almost required to pick something from Nashville Skyline. Lay Lady Lay has always been a favorite.

  40. Easy call for me… Hands down, “Seven Curses.” A story that never, ever tires…

  41. The best ARE the alternate versions of Visions of Johanna…titled “Freeze Out”…one with The Hawks, and there’s another done with a different studio band. Completely different readings of what could be Bob’s best song ever.
    Also the Oh Mercy outtakes are awesome.

    Wanna hear any?

    I win

  42. I’m partial to the cover of “The Mighty Quinn” from The Basement Tapes. I guess it’s becuase so many rock bands of the ’60s liked covering Dylan it was nice to hear the formula reversed.

  43. “It’s all over now baby blue” from the film “don’t look back”. It says everything.

  44. My favorite Dylan outtake is also “Blind Willie McTell” from Infidels.

    Thanks -

  45. I would have to say teh Live version of Hurricaine off the Rolling Thunder Bootleg -

    WOW…

  46. there’s no need to dig too deep to identify dylan’s greatest outtake (and perhaps the greatest outtake in rock history). i’m talking about “positively 4th street.”

    doesn’t count? it was recorded during the highway 61 revisited sessions but didn’t go on the album…

  47. “Visions of Johanna” on the No Direction Home soundtrack is absolutely unbelievable.

  48. My favorite Dylan outtake is The Death Of Emmett Till from the 1962 Cynthia Gooding Interview

  49. I’m going to have to say “Catfish” from the Bootleg Series Vol. 1-3. A very bluesy, mellow side of Dylan, and although short and relegated to “outtake” status, it still is very high quality, which is not surprising from Bob. Makes me jealous to think of how easy the man can write songs.

    I never had a chance to see Catfish pitch, other than some DVD’s, but am full aware of his credentials and was sad to see him pass away from Lou Gehrig’s disease a few years back. Seeing footage of the “Mustache Gang” Oakland A’s makes me long for the days when the game was more colorful and less business.

  50. I guess I will have to go with the live version of Hurricane from the Bootleg series.

    Thanks for everything.

  51. It’s been said before, for good reason, and I gotta go with Isis from the Rolling Thunder CD. He literally detonates the song. It’s a bunch of long verses that he sings like Coltrane, infusing each line and each phrase with its own edge and character. He kills the song. And the band goes wild.

  52. It Takes A Lot To Laugh, It Takes A Train To Cry [Alternate Take] from No Direction Home

  53. “Idiot Wind” from The Bootleg Series Vol.2

    It’s just so intimate, it feels like he’s on the verge on having a nervous breakdown at any moment. I wouldn’t be surprised if Conner Oberest learned to sing from listening to this one track over and over again.

  54. It’s a toss-up for me between two.

    One is “All you have to do is Dream #1″ on Vol. 1 of the Genuine Basment Tapes. Muted electrics, crazy organs, and the ridiculous line “and I can get corn for a nickel, yes and what an earful I can get, every I time I try and go get me a little tickle”. The combination will cause uncontrollable head bobbing and laughter.

    Two is an unreleased test press of “Lily, Rosemary And The Jack Of Hearts” that came out on the “Blood on the Tapes” bootleg. Just Bob and an acoustic. Really wish this one woulda made “Tracks”

  55. I like “Rocks & Gravel” or “Talkin’ John Birch Paranoid Blues” from the Freewheelin’ outtakes.

  56. ‘ballad of a thin man’ from royal albert hall ‘66. an already intense song is taken to the next level.

  57. Talkin’ John Birch Paranoid Blues.

  58. My favourite outtakes are the entire Genuine Basement Tapes! I really cherish those recordings. Others that come to mind are “I’ll Keep It With Mine” solo piano, “Can You Please Crawl Out Your Window?” single version (there’s another version that isn’t as good), and definitely “Blind Willie McTell”. The “Idiot Wind” from the Bootleg Series Vol. 2 is pretty great too.

    Oh! And “I Ain’t Got No Home” with The Band from the Woody Guthrie Tribute Concert ‘67. It’s not a Dylan song, obviously, but what a great version!

  59. I’ve got to go with the “Desolation Row” (my favourite Dylan song) from The Bootleg Series Vol. 7.

  60. My first Dylan show was Dylan with the Grateful Dead at Giant’s Stadium, NJ in the summer of ‘87. Since then I have always been partial to Dylan with Jerry and the boys backing him up… so my pick is “In the Summertime” from disc two of the five disc Dylan and the Dead rehearsals.

  61. Te best Outtake for me is “I’ll keep it with mine” from the Bootleg series 1-3
    Great recording, wonderful piano and terrific song!!

  62. Bob Dylan performing “Love Sick” at the 1998 Grammy Awards. Part way through the performance Michael Portoy jumps on stage and dances shirtlless. SOY BOMB!

    This recording can be found on the promo disc: Million Miles: Live Recordings, 1997-1999

  63. WHERE ARE YOU TONIGHT (JOURNEY THROUGH WHITE HEAT) is my favorite and one of the most unappreciated dylan tunes of all time. Take the gravitas storytelling and imagery of TANGLED UP IN BLUE, and the swelling chorus from LIKE A ROLLING STONE and you have a masterpiece.

    “i left town at dawn, with marcel and st john: strong men belittled by doubt” — the roadtrip with your buddies is just beginning: this comes on the stereo, and you wonder am I the “I” this time or am I marcel and st john. Ive had both trips.

  64. I’m gonna go with “I Shall Be Released” from the Greatest Hits Vol II.
    I absolutely love this stripped down version!

  65. My Fav Dylan outtake comes from the 1969 sessions with Johnny Cash - the Elvis song “Thats Alright Mama”. Such a spirited performance! Thanks for the wonderful wesite. I look forward to checking it every morning!
    - BP

  66. Hmmm… Probabley Hurricane. it’s on Bootlegs. :) Dylan at his best!

  67. Its got to be his version of Lost Highway in Dont Look Back. He messes up the lyrics but that version has always stuck with me.

  68. Yes, I received your letter yesterday
    (About the time the door knob broke)
    When you asked how I was doing
    Was that some kind of joke?
    All these people that you mention
    Yes, I know them, they’re quite lame
    I had to rearrange their faces
    And give them all another name
    Right now I can’t read too good
    Don’t send me no more letters no
    Not unless you mail them
    From Desolation Row

  69. I’ll Keep It With Mine–maybe my favorite all-around, outtake or not.

  70. “Chimes of Freedom” (live) from the No Direction Home DVD/CD compilation. Dylan seems to be belting (yelling) this one out, not singing it. For me, I always hear an extra big of “sticking it to the masses” coming out of him on this version. Maybe even a pleading.

  71. Favorite outtake? That’s a tough question, but I’d go with “Freeze Out” #1 on the boot THIN WILD MERCURY MUSIC. The raw vocal of that track hits me in the gut.

  72. My favorite Bob Dylan song is the old blues song, “Rolling & Tumbling” but I like all his songs.

  73. “Happy Birthday” on YouTube. For this, he should have won the Nobel Prize for Literature.

    Damn that Doris Lessing.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8BDIs9gyYW4

  74. My favorite has to be “Rock Me Mama,” from the Pat Garret & Billy the Kid session–just a gorgeous, simple song.

  75. Witchita - Freewheelin’ Outtakes

    In my opinion, this song basically shows how effortlessly Bob Dylan could pull off the traditional blues covers and make them his own.
    I’ve searched for versions of this song that are similar to his and none even come close.

    I feel that this take is often overlooked among Dylan freaks - - I’m listenin to it right now and its givin me the urge to take a tear into the country on my motorbike - - goddamn its good!

  76. The live version of “Romance in Durango” on Bootleg Series Vol 4(?) when he asks “Remember Durango Larry?”.

  77. The Death of Emmett Till- Freewheelin’ Sessions

  78. Tombstone Blues off of the No Direction Home soundtrack with, I believe, The Chambers Brothers.

  79. My favorite Dylan outtake is an odd choice, but with good reason. It’s “Wild Wood Flower” which is a Basement Tapes outtake, available on the Genuine Basement Tapes, Vol. 4. It’s jangly and happy, and any time Bob Dylan is happy, it is extremely catching. Makes me feel good, makes me feel like I’m riding down a dirt road with grandpa and a bb gun.

  80. Best Dylan outtake, and probably best overall song: “I’ll Keep It With Mine.”

  81. “Idiot Wind” from the bootleg series (3 cd) set. Dylan is amazing! My daughter is due in a few weeks, and i can’t wait to introduce her to Mr. Zimmerman!

    Cheers to a great website that I read daily!
    -Tim

  82. This is tough one but I will go with Bob’s “Last Thoughts on Woody Guthrie”. Its from The Bootleg series and it always makes me smile…its 5 pages of greatfullness and love

  83. The Basement Tapes as a series is my favorite collection of outtakes, with the Dylan songs on it being my favorite (I especially love the part where he cracks up in Mrs. Henry, and the completely absurd lines like “I punched myself in the face with my fist. I took my po-ta-toes down to be mashed…”).

    But if it’s a single song I have to choose I’d go with Series of Dreams.

  84. My favorite Dylan outtake is Wildflower.. because only Dylan can write a song that could be tossed aside as country filler but capture a moment millions can relate to…Dylan at his economical best.

  85. Bob and Johnny Cash doing Girl from the North Country on the Cash/Dylan 1969 bootleg. Whenever I don’t understand what Griel Marcus is talking about in Old, Weird America, I go back to this and almost figure I’ve got it figured out… What a song.

  86. I have to go with the (I Heard That) Lonesome Whistle from Freewheelin’ Outakes. How can you not love that country twang

  87. I love the unreleased version of “Sign on the Window” from The Third One Now. I think it may be the same take that appears on New Morning, but this version has strings and for some reason I think it takes the song to a more poignant level. Read my review of the Dylan box on my site Rock Turtleneck:
    http://rockturtleneck.blogspot.com/

  88. Let Me Die In My Footsteps - Freewheelin’ Sessions

    It’s a very spiritual song which always hits home for me. Also, it’s very hard for me to sing and play guitar at the same time..but I can do it with this song. It’s great to be able to pay homage and feel the song in that way!

  89. I was going to say “Desolation Row” from Royal Albert Hall, but I think it’s been taken.

    I know this may not be in the spirit of the post, but I have to say my least favorite is his version of “Ring of Fire.” As much as I love love love love love his “Girl from the North Country” with Johnny I think Bobby should stay away from Johnny.

  90. I don’t deserve to win this.

  91. My favorite “track” from Bob Dylan is “All along the watchtower” from the Second Amazing Night

  92. The track that always find it’s way back to me is “Not Dark Yet” off “Time Out Of Mind.” One of those beautiful phrases of wisdom, like a darker “Oh La La” by The Faces.

  93. can only be “She´s Your Lover Now” the solo piano version, not the version with the band.
    “The pawnbroker roared
    Also, so, so did the landlord
    The scene was so crazy, wasn’t it?
    Both were so glad
    To watch me destroy what I had
    Pain sure brings out the best in people, doesn’t it?”

    What perfect opening lines!

  94. My favorite “outtake” by far is the New York version of “You’re A Big Girl Now”, first released on Biograph. Simply stunning and heartbreaking.

  95. My favorite right now is You’re Still a Child To Me. From
    Between Saved & Shot Bootleg (Shot of Love Sessions & Outtakes) 1981.

  96. “Blind Willie McTell” is not only my favorite outtake but one of his greatest songs.

  97. The best “unreleased” Dylan tune is his version of Black Cross. Simple guitar with Dylans spoken retelling of the story of Hezikiah Jones. I love the way Dylan tells the story and the way he growls “‘You don’t understand,’ said the white man’s preacher, ‘there’s a lot of ways for a good man to be WICKED!’”
    It’s a sad story about a man who’s only crime was that he believed in the good of people more than the good of God.

  98. “Forever Young/Baby Let Me Follow You Down” from The Last Waltz. So awesome that commentary seems kinda pointless … just go listen to it — or, better yet, watch it.

  99. this is my favorite dylan outtake.

    “I can’t leave her behind” from Eat the Document

  100. I LOVE “Santa Fe” off the Bootleg Series vol: 1-3. Great example of Dylan’s ability to craft a low-fi pop masterpiece (a la Robert Pollard).

  101. one of the tracks that didn’t make it on to Infidels-foot of pride

  102. I don’t think this is the best Dylan recording, but I just like it. I’m not even sure where I downloaded it from, but it’s Dylan singing “Walk the line” with Paul Simon and after the last chorus they shift in “Blue moon over Kentucky”. Great, pure and silly.

  103. The best outtake of Dylan I’ve ever heard is a studio drop of “Went to See The Gypsy”, with only the organ and Bob, and it’s a surreal, jazzy version of the song. Let me know if you want a copy of it.

    Nate

  104. My favorite today is the cover of Karma Chameleon he did between takes for a video of some song off Infidels. Unreleased? Not even recorded! I’d love to hear it, though.

  105. “Don’t Ever Take Yourself Away”, a Shot Of Love outtake from the Genuine Bootleg Series.

  106. My favorite bootleg is Gospeller 4/20/80. It’s so much fun listening to Dylan get all religious on stage. Classic bootleg and great sound quality. I also like the Dylan Dead rehearsals, same reason, it’s fun to listen to.

  107. Hey, if its not too late…I Wanna Be Your lover from Biograph. Thanks for your blog.

  108. Visions of Johanna - 5/26/66 Albert Hall acoustic set

  109. I’d have to say “Boots of Spanish Leather” is my favorite Dylan prose. A beautiful piece of work.

  110. I’m going to go with the home recording of “I Was Young When I Left Home” from the No Direction Home soundtrack. Thanks for the chance to win.

  111. Bonny Ship the Diamond on the Real Basement Tapes

  112. who won? i wish it was me :(

  113. Gotta be ‘She’s your lover now’. Mainly because it makes me think of her. And makes me glad I’m not him.

  114. Ok, so the winner never returned our email. We are picking another winner today, so please enter valid email addresses so we can get you these CDs, tickets, etc. in the future.

    Thanks - A.D.

  115. Too late to enter but my favorite outtake is the verson of I shall Be Released with Richard Manual.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>